Credibility Comparison
Fox News vs MSNBC: Which Is More Credible?
Fox News and MSNBC are the two most watched cable news networks in America, and they sit at opposite ends of the political spectrum. But political orientation is not the same as credibility. Here is what the evidence actually shows about how each network operates.
What we evaluate
PressGrade scores every media figure and outlet on five behavioral criteria: Factual Accuracy, Correction Culture, Source Transparency, Content Integrity, and Editorial Independence.
Read our full methodology →What the evidence shows about Fox News
Fox News has significant and documented credibility concerns across multiple criteria. Its primetime programming has largely abandoned the distinction between news and opinion, presenting advocacy in a format that mimics news reporting. Its factual accuracy record includes a notable volume of claims rated false or misleading by independent fact-checkers, and its correction culture is inconsistent. Fox does score better on source transparency — its ownership and political orientation are publicly known and not hidden from its audience.
What the evidence shows about MSNBC
MSNBC performs better than Fox News across most credibility criteria, but still has meaningful weaknesses. Its factual accuracy record is stronger, and it maintains a more consistent correction culture. However, MSNBC has a documented pattern of editorial alignment with Democratic politics that undermines genuine independence. Like Fox, it blurs the line between news and opinion in its primetime programming, presenting strongly partisan analysis in a news format.
Key differences
- •Fox News has a significantly weaker factual accuracy record than MSNBC based on independent fact-checker findings.
- •MSNBC issues corrections more consistently and prominently than Fox News.
- •Both networks blur the line between news and opinion, but do so in different ways.
- •Fox News scores better on source transparency in the sense that its political orientation is openly acknowledged.
- •Neither network demonstrates strong editorial independence.
The bottom line
Both networks have real credibility weaknesses that consumers should understand. MSNBC performs better on the criteria that most directly predict trustworthiness, but neither network represents a reliable primary news source.
Related assessments
See how your sources score
Search any journalist, host, or outlet free. No account required.
Search PressGrade